Socrates's question
Do morals have anything to do with religion? Supernaturalists say they do. Their theory is, an action is good if God commands that it is good. Alternatively, an action is bad if God says that it is bad. So murdering is bad because one of the ten commandments says "thou shalt not kill". This kind of theory of morality is nice because it makes morals objective (have an truth value that is independent of what we think). We can resolve the differences between cultures by saying that there is only one right way of doing things, and that is what God commands. So cultures which practice polygamy (custom of having more than one wife) are wrong.
Generally, arguments which rely on the existence of God are considered bad arguments. This is because the existence of God is controversial in itself. Nevertheless, a stronger way to attack such an argument is to assume that there is a God, and show that the argument doesn't work anyway. Socrates, an ancient Greek philosopher, thus managed to show how Supernalism fails as a theory.
He asked: are actions good because God commands them, or does God command them because they are good? This question is very significant for Supernaturalism because it creates a dilemma. If it's the latter, then Supernaturalists must find another theory for what is good; if it's the former, then we can generate some pretty counter-intuitive examples as to why this cannot be. If murdering is wrong because God says it is, then God could say that torturing babies is good and then it would be! But this is absurd: we would never believe that torturing babies is good, no matter how much God said that it was. Some argue that God would not command such a thing. But what if he did?
So you don't have to be religious to be moral.
Further Reading:
- Gensler, H. J., 1998, Chapter 2, Ethics: A Contemporary Introduction, Routledge
- "Euthyphro" by Plato from The Collected Dialogues of Plato Including the Letters, Ed. Edith Hamilton & Huntington Cairns, Princeton University Press
posted by Niki Saunders @ 5:58 PM
27 Comments:
I like your blog, I have not seen many philosophical blogs around.
I think that 2500 years ago Socrates solved a problem that many people is not able to see nowadays and that is the source of much intolerance.
I will add a link to your blog in mine, but I will have to open a new section which might me called "philosophical blogs"
I found this site using [url=http://google.com]google.com[/url] And i want to thank you for your work. You have done really very good site. Great work, great site! Thank you!
Sorry for offtopic
Who knows where to download XRumer 5.0 Palladium?
Help, please. All recommend this program to effectively advertise on the Internet, this is the best program!
No prescription viagra soft Online verapamil World delivery azulfidine No prescription omnicef Online motrin Discount norplant
I'm looking for things to think about while i'm bored. you see, im in the navy and i deploy for x months soon without coming into port. boredom doesnt quite descibe long periods of time in a small space with nothing to do.
comment4, natasha alam nude, 0512,
, cintia dicker nude, >:[[, ellie kemper nude, 8-], sarah butler nude, >:-D, michelle ryan nude, :-[[,
comment4, gillian anderson nude, 66873, cobie smulders nude, 52979, emma watson naakt, 019, kim kardashian nackt, 461824,
comment2, kristen bell naked, efgv, amanda peet nude, =-DDD, joan severance nude, %DD,
comment2, ashley tisdale nuda, 6999, kristy swanson nude, >:-]]], viva bianca nude, eedo,
comment6, sexy stars ever, >:((, nudity 200 celebs, 9262, rachael ray nude, 4524,
comment6, celebrities naked, 7341, emilie de ravin nude, 5027,
comment5, kate beckinsale sex scene, yjehva, missy peregrym nude, :-OO,
comment3, christy hemme playboy, znz, emma watson nuda, ebfn, elizabeth banks nude, 48903,
comment2, willa holland nude, %)), minnie driver nude, >:-((, cassandra peterson nude, owd,
comment6, katherine heigl sex scene, 714, ali larter nude, 630, amber heard nude, rukbdp, helena bonham carter nude, 856988,
comment1, ana de la reguera nude, wls, megan fox oben ohne, 8-((, amanda holden porn, :OOO, christina aguilera nackt, 873,
comment2, morena baccarin nude, twwrp, jennifer connelly naked, 334707, alyson hannigan nude, 8123,
comment4, danielle panabaker nude, wlsr, brittany murphy nude, 015,
, mariah carey desnuda, vgvua, malin akerman nude, >:], stacy keibler nude, 110641,
comment2, danielle panabaker nude, 8-[,
comment4, cameron diaz nackt, :OO, danielle lloyd nude, >:-]]], erika christensen nude, 966,
, jennifer coolidge nude, 8656,
comment1, kate bosworth nude, enrt, alicia silverstone nude, aizv, roselyn sanchez hot, %]]], raquel welch nude, zlvb,
comment6, alison brie nude, %[[[,
comment5, betsy russell nude, 133328, dannii minogue playboy, rcnytk,
comment5, sonya walger nude, 313018, maggie q naked, :-DD,
Post a Comment
Links to this post:
Create a Link
<< Home